Garmin vs Apple Watch: Which Is Right for You?

Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. When you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our blog and allows us to continue providing helpful content. Thank you for your support!

Note on Pricing: All prices in this guide are listed in Canadian Dollars (CAD). Prices may vary based on retailer, sales, and promotions. We recommend checking current prices on Amazon.ca, Best Buy Canada, and Apple.ca for the best deals.

Introduction: The Ultimate Smartwatch Showdown

Choosing between a Garmin watch and an Apple Watch isn’t just about picking a fitness tracker—it’s about deciding what kind of technology will sit on your wrist every single day for years to come. Indeed, these two brands represent fundamentally different philosophies: Garmin builds fitness trackers with smartwatch features, while Apple creates smartwatches with fitness tracking capabilities.

This distinction matters more than you might think. In fact, your choice will impact everything from how often you charge your device to what activities you can track. Furthermore, it affects how you interact with your phone, and whether your watch will still be functional after a week-long backcountry hiking trip.

What You’ll Learn in This Guide

In this comprehensive 2026 guide, we’ll break down every important factor to help you make the right decision. Whether you’re a serious athlete training for your next marathon, a casual fitness enthusiast trying to stay healthy, or someone who simply wants the best smartwatch technology, we’ll show you which option truly fits your lifestyle.

Quick Comparison: Garmin vs Apple Watch at a Glance

When to Choose Garmin:

✅ You prioritize multi-day battery life (weeks, not hours)
✅ Serious training metrics and performance analytics matter
✅ You participate in outdoor adventures (hiking, trail running, cycling)
✅ You use an Android phone or switch phones frequently
✅ You want rugged durability and solar charging options
✅ GPS accuracy is critical for your activities

When to Choose Apple Watch:

✅ You’re deeply invested in the Apple ecosystem (iPhone, AirPods, MacBook)
✅ Smartwatch features trump specialized fitness tracking
✅ You value seamless app integration and third-party support
✅ Taking calls and replying to messages from your wrist is essential
✅ You don’t mind daily charging in exchange for advanced features
✅ Health monitoring (ECG, blood oxygen, fall detection) is a priority

Detailed Comparison: Breaking Down the Key Differences

1. Battery Life: The Deal-Breaker for Many

This is often the single most important factor when choosing between these watches.

Apple Watch Battery Life:

Apple Watch Series 11: Up to 18-24 hours (requires daily charging)
Apple Watch SE 3: Up to 18 hours (daily charging required)
Apple Watch Ultra 3: Up to 42 hours normal use, 72 hours low power mode
GPS Tracking: 10-14 hours for intensive workouts

Even the Ultra 3, Apple’s most rugged model, requires charging every 1-2 days with typical use. Consequently, if you track sleep at night and exercise during the day, you’ll need to find time to charge—usually while showering or working at a desk.

Garmin Battery Life:

Forerunner 165 (entry-level): 11 days smartwatch, 19 hours GPS
Forerunner 570 (mid-range): 10 days smartwatch, 19 hours GPS
Venu 4 (lifestyle): 14 days smartwatch
Fenix 8 Pro (premium): 27 days smartwatch, 95 hours GPS
Enduro 3 (ultra-endurance): 36 days smartwatch, 200+ hours GPS
Instinct 3 Solar: Unlimited battery with sufficient sunlight

Real-World Impact:

One user who switched from Apple Watch to Garmin shared: “I used to have to charge my Apple Watch every single night. During a backpacking trip in the Grand Canyon, I had to plan charging stops or risk losing all tracking. In contrast, with my Garmin Fenix, I’ve gone 5 days without charging even while doing daily activities.”

Winner: Garmin dominates battery life in every category. Unless you’re fine with daily charging, Garmin is clearly the better choice.

👉Shop Garmin Watches on Amazon

2. Fitness Tracking & Training Features

Both brands excel at fitness tracking, however, they approach it very differently.

Garmin’s Fitness Philosophy:

Garmin watches are designed by and for athletes. Furthermore, every feature exists to make you a better, smarter, more efficient athlete.

Key Garmin Fitness Features:

Training Readiness: Tells you if your body is ready for intense workouts based on sleep, HRV, stress, and recovery
Training Load & Status: Prevents overtraining by monitoring cumulative training stress
VO2 Max Tracking: Auto-detects your maximum heart rate and provides accurate cardiovascular fitness estimates
Race Predictions: Estimates finish times for 5K, 10K, half marathon, and marathon based on current fitness
Running Dynamics: Detailed metrics like cadence, vertical oscillation, ground contact time (requires chest strap for full data)
Performance Condition: Real-time analysis during runs showing if you’re performing above or below your fitness level
Body Battery: Energy monitoring that helps you understand when to push hard and when to rest
Heat & Altitude Acclimation: Tracks how your body adapts to environmental conditions
Multi-Sport Modes: 30+ activity profiles with sport-specific metrics

Apple Watch Fitness Features:

Apple’s approach prioritizes accessibility and motivation over deep analytics. Additionally, the interface is beautiful and encouraging, though less detailed than Garmin’s offerings.

Key Apple Watch Fitness Features:

Activity Rings: Simple, motivating visualization of Move, Exercise, and Stand goals
Workout App: Tracks 100+ workout types with basic metrics
Heart Rate Zones: Shows effort levels during exercise
Running Power: New metric for runners (similar to cycling power)
Swimming Tracking: Automatic stroke detection and lap counting
Apple Fitness+: Integrated workout classes (subscription required)
Workout Sharing: Compete and share achievements with friends
Personalized Metrics: Custom heart rate zones and activity goals
Recovery & Load: Basic training load indicators (new in watchOS 11)

Data Depth Comparison:

After a 10K run, here’s what each watch tells you:

Garmin: Distance, pace, elevation, heart rate zones, VO2 max estimate, training effect (aerobic/anaerobic), recovery time needed, race time predictions, performance condition, running dynamics (with chest strap), lactate threshold, detailed split analysis, and how this run impacts your overall training load.

Apple Watch: Distance, pace, elevation gain, average heart rate, heart rate zones, calories burned, route map, splits, and whether you achieved a personal best.

Winner: Garmin for serious athletes; Apple Watch for general fitness enthusiasts. Specifically, if training analytics matter, Garmin is unmatched. Conversely, if you want simple, motivating tracking, Apple Watch excels.

👉 Shop Apple Watch on Amazon

3. Smartwatch Features & Daily Usability

This is where Apple Watch truly shines. In fact, it outperforms Garmin significantly in this category.

Apple Watch Smart Features:

The Apple Watch is essentially a miniature iPhone on your wrist.

What Apple Watch Does Better:

App Ecosystem: Thousands of third-party apps (Spotify, WhatsApp, Uber, banking apps, games)
Phone Calls: Take calls directly from your watch with built-in speaker and microphone
Message Replies: Full keyboard, voice dictation, and preset responses
Siri Integration: Voice commands for everything (“Hey Siri, set a timer for 15 minutes”)
Apple Pay: Contactless payments work everywhere that accepts tap-to-pay
Camera Control: Use your watch as a remote viewfinder and shutter for iPhone photos
Maps Navigation: Turn-by-turn directions with haptic feedback on your wrist
Music Streaming: Native Spotify, Apple Music, and podcast apps with offline storage
Find My Integration: Locate your iPhone, AirPods, or other Apple devices
Seamless Ecosystem: Unlocks Mac, controls HomePods, interfaces with iPad

Garmin Smart Features:

Garmin watches include smartwatch basics but lack the deep integration Apple offers. Nevertheless, they provide essential functionality for most users.

What Garmin Offers:

Smartphone Notifications: View texts, calls, emails, and app alerts (limited reply capabilities)
Garmin Pay: Contactless payments (not as widely supported as Apple Pay)
Music Storage: Offline Spotify, Amazon Music, Deezer (Apple Music requires workarounds)
Connect IQ Apps: Third-party apps and watch faces (limited compared to Apple)
Android & iPhone Compatible: Works with both platforms (huge advantage over Apple Watch)
Weather Forecasts: Detailed weather data
Calendar Integration: View appointments and reminders
Voice Assistance: Limited compared to Siri

Fenix 8 Pro Note: The latest Fenix 8 Pro includes a speaker and microphone for voice commands. Moreover, it has LTE-M connectivity for satellite messaging, thereby narrowing the gap with Apple’s smart features.

Real-World Scenarios:

Scenario 1: You’re at the grocery store with dirty hands while cooking.

With Apple Watch: “Hey Siri, add eggs to my shopping list.” Done.
With Garmin: Pull out your phone to update your list.

Scenario 2: You receive an urgent text while running.

With Apple Watch: Read it, dictate a voice reply, or send a quick preset response—all from your wrist.
With Garmin: Read the notification, but you’ll need to finish your run and grab your phone to reply.

Winner: Apple Watch dominates smartwatch functionality. If you want a true wrist computer, Apple wins easily.

4. Health Monitoring & Medical Features

Both watches track health metrics, however, Apple Watch includes FDA-cleared medical features that set it apart.

Apple Watch Health Features:

Apple has invested heavily in health monitoring with FDA clearances for several features. As a result, it offers medical-grade capabilities.

Advanced Health Monitoring:

ECG (Electrocardiogram): Medical-grade heart rhythm analysis that can detect AFib
Blood Oxygen Monitoring: SpO2 measurements during sleep and on-demand
High Blood Pressure Detection: NEW in 2026 – monitors for signs of hypertension over 30-day periods
Fall Detection: Automatically calls emergency services if you take a hard fall
Crash Detection: Detects severe car accidents and contacts emergency responders
Sleep Apnea Notifications: Alerts you to possible sleep apnea requiring medical evaluation
Heart Rate Alerts: Notifies of abnormally high or low heart rates
Temperature Sensing: Wrist temperature tracking for cycle tracking and illness detection
Sleep Score: NEW – comprehensive sleep quality analysis
Vitals App: Tracks key overnight health metrics and alerts to concerning changes
Noise Monitoring: Warns when ambient noise could damage hearing
Menstrual Cycle Tracking: Period predictions with retrospective ovulation estimates

Garmin Health Features:

Garmin focuses on wellness and performance rather than medical diagnostics. Instead, it emphasizes athletic recovery and training optimization.

Health & Wellness Tracking:

Pulse Ox: Blood oxygen saturation monitoring (similar to Apple)
Body Battery: Proprietary energy monitoring based on stress, sleep, and activity
Stress Tracking: All-day stress level monitoring with relaxation breathing exercises
Advanced Sleep Monitoring: Sleep stages, sleep score, and personalized insights
HRV Status: Heart rate variability tracking for recovery insights
Fitness Age: Compares your fitness level to average for your age
Health Snapshot: 2-minute session capturing key health stats
Respiration Rate: Breathing rate throughout the day and during sleep
Hydration Tracking: Log water intake (Venu series)
Women’s Health: Menstrual cycle and pregnancy tracking

The Medical Device Difference:

Apple Watch has FDA clearance for its ECG and irregular rhythm notifications. This means it meets medical device standards for detecting atrial fibrillation. Moreover, several users have credited their Apple Watch with detecting serious heart conditions that led to life-saving medical intervention.

In contrast, Garmin watches provide valuable health insights but don’t have the same medical device certifications. Therefore, they’re wellness tools, not diagnostic devices.

Winner: Apple Watch for medical-grade health monitoring. Garmin for holistic wellness and athletic recovery tracking.

5. GPS Accuracy & Navigation

This feature is critical for runners, cyclists, and outdoor adventurers. Indeed, GPS performance can make or break your outdoor experience.

Garmin GPS Technology:

GPS is Garmin’s heritage—they’ve been building GPS devices since 1989. Consequently, their expertise in this area is unmatched.

Garmin GPS Advantages:

Multi-Band GNSS: Premium models use multiple satellite systems (GPS, GLONASS, Galileo) on multiple frequencies for incredible accuracy
SatIQ Technology: Automatically switches between single and multi-band GPS to optimize battery life
Pre-Loaded Maps: Full topographic maps on Fenix and Forerunner 965/970
Turn-by-Turn Navigation: On-watch directions for complex routes
ClimbPro: Shows remaining ascent on climbs during trail runs and hikes
TracBack Routing: Navigate back to your starting point
Breadcrumb Trails: Follow previously recorded routes
Offline Maps: All navigation works without phone connection
Ski Resort Maps: Pre-loaded trail maps for 2,000+ ski resorts
Golf Courses: 43,000+ courses with distances to greens and hazards

Apple Watch GPS:

Apple Watch has improved GPS significantly in recent years. However, it still trails Garmin for outdoor accuracy in challenging conditions.

Apple Watch GPS Features:

Dual-Frequency GPS: Ultra 3 model includes multi-band GPS for better accuracy
Route Tracking: Records your path during workouts
Compass & Waypoints: Mark locations and navigate to them (Ultra models)
Backtrack: Navigate back to start using breadcrumb trail (Ultra models)
Maps Integration: Turn-by-turn directions via iPhone integration
Elevation Tracking: Barometric altimeter measures elevation gain

Real-World Accuracy Testing:

Multiple runners testing Garmin Forerunner vs Apple Watch on the same routes consistently find the following results:

Open areas: Both watches perform similarly
Urban canyons (tall buildings): Garmin multi-band GPS maintains accuracy; Apple Watch can lose signal or show erratic tracking
Dense forest trails: Garmin stays more consistent
Route complexity: Garmin handles switchbacks and tight turns better

Winner: Garmin for GPS accuracy and outdoor navigation. While Apple Watch is improving, it can’t match Garmin’s dedicated GPS technology, especially in challenging environments.

6. Durability & Build Quality

Apple Watch Construction:

Apple Watches are beautifully designed. However, they prioritize aesthetics over ruggedness.

Build Materials:

Aluminum Models: Lightweight but prone to scratches
Stainless Steel: More durable, heavier, polished finish
Titanium (Ultra 3): Lightweight, strong, scratch-resistant
Sapphire Crystal: Premium models use scratch-resistant glass
Water Resistance: 50 meters (Series/SE), 100 meters (Ultra 3 – suitable for diving)

Durability Concerns:

Touchscreen can crack from impacts
No bezel protection around the screen
Sleek design leaves glass exposed
Not designed for extreme outdoor abuse

Garmin Construction:

Garmin watches are built for harsh outdoor conditions. In fact, they’re designed to survive environments that would destroy most smartwatches.

Build Materials:

Fiber-Reinforced Polymer: Lightweight, durable standard cases
Stainless Steel Bezels: Protect screen from impacts
Titanium Cases: Premium models offer exceptional strength-to-weight ratio
Sapphire Crystal: Available on mid-range and higher models
Corning Gorilla Glass: Entry-level models use chemically strengthened glass
Water Resistance: 50-100 meters standard; Fenix 8 Pro rated to 40m for diving
Military Standard (MIL-STD-810): Many models tested for thermal, shock, and water resistance

Durability Advantages:

Button controls work when wet, with gloves, or in cold weather
Raised bezels protect screens from impacts
Built to withstand drops, bumps, and extreme conditions
Proven durability in marathons, Ironman races, and ultramarathons

One Garmin user reported: “I’ve used my Fenix for 2 years through countless hikes, workouts, and travel. The screen is still scratch-free despite taking some serious abuse. It’s genuinely built for the outdoors.”

Winner: Garmin for durability. While Apple Watch is well-made, it’s not designed for extreme conditions. Therefore, if you’re rough on watches, choose Garmin.

7. Display Quality & Visibility

Apple Watch Displays:

Apple’s Retina displays are gorgeous—among the best screens on any smartwatch. In particular, they excel at indoor viewing and media consumption.

Display Technology:

LTPO OLED/AMOLED: Vibrant colors, deep blacks, excellent contrast
Always-On Display: Shows time and complications without raising wrist
Bright Screen: Up to 2,000 nits brightness for outdoor visibility
Touchscreen: Smooth, responsive multi-touch interface
Large Sizes: 42mm, 46mm (Series 11), 49mm (Ultra 3)

Advantages: Beautiful indoors, great for viewing photos and notifications, smooth animations
Drawbacks: Can be hard to see in direct sunlight, battery drain from bright displays

Garmin Displays:

Garmin offers two display technologies depending on model. Each has distinct advantages for different use cases.

MIP (Memory-in-Pixel) Displays:

Always-on, ultra-low power consumption
Exceptional visibility in direct sunlight (actually gets easier to read)
Muted colors, less impressive indoors
Found on: Instinct 3 Solar, Enduro 3, Fenix 8 Solar

AMOLED Displays:

Vibrant colors, high contrast like Apple Watch
Touchscreen capable
Shorter battery life than MIP
Found on: Venu 4, Forerunner 265/570/970, Fenix 8 AMOLED

Winner: Apple Watch for indoor display quality. Garmin MIP for outdoor visibility. Notably, Garmin AMOLED models offer a middle ground between these extremes.

8. Pricing & Value

Apple Watch Pricing (CAD):

Model	Price	Best For
Apple Watch SE 3	$329 – $429	Budget-conscious iPhone users
Apple Watch Series 11	$549 – $849	Most iPhone users
Apple Watch Ultra 3	$1,079	Extreme sports, long battery needs

👉 Shop Apple Watch on Amazon

Garmin Pricing (CAD):

Model	Price	Best For
Forerunner 165	$437.74	Entry-level runners
Instinct 3	$579.98	Budget outdoor enthusiasts
Venu 4	$769.99	Lifestyle fitness tracking
Forerunner 570	$796.81	Serious runners
Forerunner 970	$1,099.98	Elite runners/triathletes
Enduro 3	$1,319.99	Ultra-endurance athletes
Fenix 8 Pro	$1,819.99	Premium multi-sport/adventure

👉Shop Garmin Watches on Amazon

Value Considerations:

Apple Watch: Requires iPhone (adds to total cost if you don’t have one). AppleCare+ recommended ($109-$179 CAD). Additionally, many features require subscriptions (Apple Fitness+, cellular plan).

Garmin: Works with any phone and includes all features without subscriptions. Furthermore, it offers longer lifespan due to exceptional battery life and durability. Moreover, Garmin watches tend to have better resale value over time.

Winner: Tie. Apple Watch SE 3 offers incredible value for iPhone users. Meanwhile, Garmin provides better long-term value for athletes due to no subscription costs and longer device lifespan.

9. App Ecosystem & Third-Party Integration

Apple Watch:

The App Store for Apple Watch includes thousands of apps. As a result, it offers unmatched versatility for daily tasks.

Popular Apple Watch Apps:

Spotify, YouTube Music, Apple Music (full streaming)
WhatsApp, Telegram, Messenger (full messaging)
Banking apps with transaction alerts
Uber, Lyft for ride-hailing
Carrot Weather, Dark Sky alternatives
Games and entertainment apps
Productivity apps (Todoist, Things, Notion)

Garmin:

Connect IQ store offers apps, watch faces, and data fields. However, the selection is more limited than Apple’s ecosystem.

Garmin App Integration:

Strava (seamless sync)
TrainingPeaks (coaching platform integration)
MyFitnessPal (nutrition tracking)
Komoot (route planning)
Spotify, Amazon Music, Deezer (offline music)
Limited third-party apps compared to Apple

Winner: Apple Watch dominates app selection and third-party integration. In fact, it’s not even close in this category.

10. Platform Compatibility

Apple Watch:

Only works with iPhone (iPhone 11 or later with iOS 26)
Requires iCloud account
Family Setup allows kids without iPhone to use Apple Watch
No Android support whatsoever

Garmin:

Works with iPhone AND Android
Garmin Connect app available on both platforms
Easy to switch phones without losing data
True platform independence

Winner: Garmin for platform flexibility. In contrast, Apple Watch locks you into the iOS ecosystem completely.

Head-to-Head: Model Comparisons

Budget Battle: Apple Watch SE 3 vs Garmin Forerunner 165

Apple Watch SE 3 (CAD $329-$429)

✅ Best value Apple Watch
✅ Full smartwatch features
✅ Basic fitness tracking
❌ 18-hour battery life
❌ No ECG or blood oxygen
❌ Aluminum case only

Garmin Forerunner 165 (CAD $437.74)

✅ 11-day battery life
✅ Advanced running metrics
✅ AMOLED display
❌ Basic smart features
❌ No maps
❌ iPhone users lose some functionality

Verdict: Apple Watch SE 3 for iPhone users wanting a smartwatch. Conversely, Forerunner 165 is ideal for dedicated runners.

Mid-Range Matchup: Apple Watch Series 11 vs Garmin Venu 4

Apple Watch Series 11 (CAD $549-$849)

✅ Premium smartwatch experience
✅ ECG and advanced health features
✅ Massive app ecosystem
✅ Beautiful display
❌ Daily charging required
❌ iPhone only

Garmin Venu 4 (CAD $769.99)

✅ 14-day battery life
✅ Comprehensive fitness tracking
✅ Platform independent
✅ Offline music storage
❌ Limited app selection
❌ Can’t reply to messages fully

Verdict: Series 11 for iPhone users prioritizing smart features. On the other hand, Venu 4 suits fitness-focused users who want great battery life.

Premium Showdown: Apple Watch Ultra 3 vs Garmin Fenix 8 Pro

Apple Watch Ultra 3 (CAD $1,079)

✅ 42-hour battery (72 low power)
✅ Satellite emergency messaging
✅ Premium iPhone integration
✅ Cellular calling
✅ Dive computer (100m)
❌ Still requires frequent charging
❌ Limited to iPhone users

Garmin Fenix 8 Pro (CAD $1,819.99)

✅ 27-day battery life
✅ Superior GPS accuracy
✅ Comprehensive mapping
✅ Platform independent
✅ Dive computer (40m)
✅ Solar charging option
❌ Much higher price
❌ Smartwatch features lag Apple

Verdict: Ultra 3 for iPhone users wanting the best Apple experience with improved battery. Alternatively, Fenix 8 Pro is perfect for serious multi-sport athletes and outdoor adventurers.

Making Your Decision: A Simple Framework

Choose Apple Watch If:

You own an iPhone and plan to keep using iPhones
Smartwatch functionality is your #1 priority
You want the best app ecosystem and third-party support
Daily charging doesn’t bother you (or you charge overnight anyway)
Health monitoring features like ECG matter to you
You value style and want a watch that looks good everywhere
Taking calls and fully interacting with messages is essential
You’re a casual exerciser, not a competitive athlete
The Apple ecosystem integration (Mac, AirPods, HomePod) appeals to you
You want the best overall smartwatch experience

Recommended Models:

Best Value: Apple Watch SE 3 (CAD $329)
Best Overall: Apple Watch Series 11 (CAD $549)
Best for Athletes: Apple Watch Ultra 3 (CAD $1,079)

👉 Shop Apple Watch on Amazon

Choose Garmin If:

Multi-day battery life is non-negotiable
You’re a serious athlete who needs advanced training analytics
You participate in outdoor adventures (trail running, hiking, cycling)
GPS accuracy is critical for your activities
You use Android or like switching between phone brands
You want a watch that survives extreme conditions
You prefer physical buttons over touchscreens
Solar charging appeals to you
You don’t need extensive smartwatch features
You want a specialized fitness tool, not a general-purpose device

Recommended Models:

Best Value: Garmin Forerunner 165 (CAD $437)
Best for Runners: Garmin Forerunner 570 (CAD $797)
Best for Adventure: Garmin Fenix 8 Pro (CAD $1,820)
Best Battery: Garmin Enduro 3 (CAD $1,320)

👉Shop Garmin Watches on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Garmin with iPhone?

Yes! All Garmin watches work perfectly with iPhone through the Garmin Connect app. You’ll get notifications, activity syncing, and access to all features. However, the only limitation is that you can’t reply to messages directly from the watch on iPhone. In contrast, Android users can send message replies.

Can I use Apple Watch without iPhone?

No. Apple Watch requires an iPhone for initial setup and ongoing functionality. While cellular models can make calls and access some features independently, you still need an iPhone to use Apple Watch properly.

Which watch is better for running?

Garmin is definitively better for serious runners. The advanced metrics (training load, VO2 max, race predictions, running dynamics), superior GPS accuracy, and multi-day battery life make it the choice of marathon and ultramarathon runners worldwide.

In contrast, Apple Watch is fine for recreational runners who just want basic tracking and motivation.

Can I shower with these watches?

Yes, both are water-resistant and shower-safe:

Apple Watch: 50m water resistance (Series/SE), 100m (Ultra) – swim and shower safe
Garmin: 50-100m water resistance across the lineup – swim and shower safe

Furthermore, the Fenix 8 Pro is even rated as a dive computer to 40 meters.

Which has better sleep tracking?

Garmin provides more detailed sleep analysis with sleep score, sleep stages, and personalized recommendations. Furthermore, the multi-day battery means you never skip sleep tracking due to charging needs.

Apple Watch recently added sleep scores and is improving rapidly. However, the daily charging requirement can interrupt consistent sleep tracking.

Do I need a subscription for either watch?

Apple Watch: No subscription required for core features. Optional subscriptions include:

Apple Fitness+ ($12.99/month CAD)
Cellular plan ($5-15/month through your carrier)
Music streaming services

Garmin: No subscriptions required at all. All features included. Music streaming requires separate Spotify/Amazon Music subscription.

Can I download music offline?

Yes, both support offline music storage:

Apple Watch: Apple Music, Spotify, Amazon Music
Garmin: Spotify, Amazon Music, Deezer (Apple Music requires manual MP3 transfer)

Which watch is more accurate for heart rate?

Both use optical heart rate sensors that perform similarly during normal activities. For maximum accuracy during intense workouts, both support connecting to chest strap heart rate monitors.

Garmin tends to be slightly more accurate during high-intensity interval training due to more mature algorithms. However, the difference is marginal for most users.

Can I track cycling/swimming/golf?

Yes, both excel at multi-sport tracking:

Apple Watch: Great for basic tracking of all sports
Garmin: Superior cycling metrics, stroke analysis for swimming, and dedicated golf features with 43,000+ course maps

Which is better for hiking?

Garmin dominates hiking and outdoor navigation. Specifically, it offers:

Pre-loaded topographic maps
TracBack routing to return to start
Longer battery life for multi-day trips
Solar charging options
Superior GPS accuracy in forests and canyons
Altimeter and barometer for elevation tracking

While Apple Watch Ultra is improving with Backtrack and waypoint features, it can’t match Garmin’s comprehensive mapping and battery life capabilities.

The Verdict: There’s No Universal Winner

After analyzing every aspect, here’s the truth: both watches are excellent at what they’re designed to do. However, they serve different purposes.

Apple Watch is the better smartwatch.

If you own an iPhone and want the most capable, feature-rich smartwatch available, nothing beats Apple Watch. The ecosystem integration, app selection, health features, and overall user experience are unmatched. Indeed, the Series 11 is the best general-purpose smartwatch money can buy.

For iPhone users who aren’t serious athletes, Apple Watch is clearly the obvious choice.

Garmin is the better fitness tracker.

If athletic performance, training analytics, multi-day adventures, and specialized sports tracking matter to you, Garmin is in a league of its own. Moreover, the battery life alone is game-changing for active people. Professional athletes and serious amateurs overwhelmingly choose Garmin for a reason.

For dedicated athletes and outdoor enthusiasts, Garmin provides tools Apple Watch simply cannot match.

Final Recommendations by User Type

Casual iPhone User (Not Athletic):
→ Apple Watch SE 3 (CAD $329) – Best value, all essential features

Fitness-Focused iPhone User:
→ Apple Watch Series 11 (CAD $549) – Perfect balance of smart and fitness features

iPhone User Who Exercises Daily:
→ Garmin Venu 4 (CAD $770) – Better fitness tracking, 14-day battery, still works with iPhone

Beginner Runner:
→ Garmin Forerunner 165 (CAD $438) – Everything you need to grow as a runner

Serious Runner/Triathlete:
→ Garmin Forerunner 970 (CAD $1,100) – Professional-grade running metrics

Outdoor Adventurer:
→ Garmin Fenix 8 Pro (CAD $1,820) – The ultimate adventure watch

Ultra-Endurance Athlete:
→ Garmin Enduro 3 (CAD $1,320) – Unbeatable battery for multi-day events

iPhone User Who Does Everything:
→ Apple Watch Ultra 3 (CAD $1,079) – Best Apple experience with improved battery

Android User:
→ Any Garmin – Apple Watch won’t work with your phone

Conclusion: Make the Choice That Fits Your Life

The question isn’t “Which is better?”—it’s “Which is better for you?” Ultimately, your personal needs should guide this decision.

If you picked up your phone right now and saw it was an iPhone, and you care more about receiving texts than analyzing your VO2 max, buy an Apple Watch. You’ll love it.

On the other hand, if you just registered for your first marathon, or you’re planning a week-long backpacking trip, or you’re tired of daily charging, buy a Garmin. You’ll wonder why you waited.

Both companies make outstanding products. Ultimately, your lifestyle, your phone, and your fitness goals will tell you which is right. Therefore, take time to consider what matters most to you before making this important decision.

Choose wisely, and enjoy your new watch!

Best Garmin Watches in 2026: Your Complete Guide to Finding the Perfect GPS Smartwatch